Logo del repository
  1. Home
 
Opzioni

Satellite evidence in human rights cases: merits and shortcomings

Claudia Candelmo
•
Valentina Nardone
2017
  • journal article

Periodico
PEACE HUMAN RIGHTS GOVERNANCE
Abstract
The present paper examines the use of satellite data as evidence in legal proceedings before international courts, with a particular focus on human rights cases. The first part of the paper analyses applicable law and provides an overview of international case law up to date, taking into consideration the jurisprudence of the International Court of Justice (ICJ), the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS), and the International Criminal Court (ICC), and highlighting general merits and shortcomings of this issue. The second part shows that even human rights courts are starting to deal with satellite evidence; among them the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) plays a prominent role. Some recent decisions rendered by it are analysed, underlying the specific value of satellite evidence in human rights cases, and taking into account some potential conflicts that may arise with human rights. In contributing to the research on the special relation between space law and human rights, the paper shows that the role of human rights courts in this context is twofold. While admitting satellite evidence in proceedings before them, human rights courts contribute to the confirmation of this kind of information as valid means of proof, although its probative value is to be assessed on a case-by-case basis. Additionally, these courts are best placed to rule on the compatibility of these means of proof with some fundamental human rights such as the right to privacy and also the freedom of information.
Archivio
https://hdl.handle.net/11390/1271028
https://ricerca.unityfvg.it/handle/11390/1271028
Diritti
open access
Soggetti
  • International Space L...

  • Human Right

  • Digital Evidence

  • Satellite Evidence

  • ECtHR

  • New Technologies.

google-scholar
Get Involved!
  • Source Code
  • Documentation
  • Slack Channel
Make it your own

DSpace-CRIS can be extensively configured to meet your needs. Decide which information need to be collected and available with fine-grained security. Start updating the theme to match your nstitution's web identity.

Need professional help?

The original creators of DSpace-CRIS at 4Science can take your project to the next level, get in touch!

Realizzato con Software DSpace-CRIS - Estensione mantenuta e ottimizzata da 4Science

  • Impostazioni dei cookie
  • Informativa sulla privacy
  • Accordo con l'utente finale
  • Invia il tuo Feedback