In this article I argue that ideas about parenthood have become a point of connection
where the neopragmatist theorists Richard Rorty and Cornel West have sought to intertwine
two of the primary responsibilities of democratic citizenship. Both Rorty and West
turn to parenthood as a reliable lodestar of virtue that allows citizens to navigate the challenging
waters of contest. I argue that this strategy exacerbates rather than mitigates the
problems that accompany the political uses of parenthood. When the experience of parenthood
is used to circumscribe the realm of political contest, the substance of political debate
can become shallow and contribute to political stagnation. When the virtuous citizenship
that parenthood is meant to instill is subject to challenge, insecurities are exacerbated and
the temptation to turn to undemocratic solutions intensifies.
